In the high-stakes world of NFL free agency, some decisions can make or break a team's future—and none are more critical than securing the right quarterbacks. As the postseason wraps up, teams are already strategizing for the offseason, and the quarterback position is at the heart of every plan. With over 60 quarterbacks starting games this season, it’s clear that depth at this position isn’t just a luxury—it’s a necessity. Here, I’ve pinpointed eight impending free-agent quarterbacks who should be at the top of their teams’ re-signing lists, even if it’s just to keep them away from rivals. But here’s where it gets controversial: not all of these players are household names, and some teams might hesitate to commit. Let’s dive in—and don’t miss the part where I challenge conventional wisdom on a few of these picks.
Green Bay Packers · Age 26
Malik Willis has essentially graduated from Matt LaFleur’s quarterback boot camp after two seasons in Green Bay. His Week 17 performance against Baltimore was nothing short of electrifying, showcasing why he’s more than just a backup. With 348 yards and three touchdowns, Willis proved he can step into a starting role if needed—a fact that won’t be lost on quarterback-hungry teams. But here’s the twist: Willis might be the most valuable backup in the NFL right now. The Packers can’t afford to let him walk, especially with Jordan Love’s injury history. Yet, some might argue that Green Bay should focus on drafting a younger prospect instead. What do you think? Is Willis worth the investment, or is there a better long-term strategy?
Pittsburgh Steelers · Age 42
With Mike Tomlin’s departure, the Steelers are at a crossroads—and their quarterback situation is murkier than ever. Aaron Rodgers, now 42, had a resurgent 2025 season, but his future in Pittsburgh is far from certain. Owner Art Rooney II hinted that Rodgers might not return without Tomlin at the helm, which raises a bold question: Should the Steelers even try to convince him to stay? A future Hall of Famer could delay retirement for one more shot, but is that a risk worth taking? And this is the part most people miss: Pittsburgh’s lack of a clear plan at quarterback could force their hand. Is Rodgers the answer, or is it time to look elsewhere?
Indianapolis Colts · Age 28
Daniel Jones’ 2026 outlook is clouded by a season-ending Achilles injury, but the Colts have already signaled their faith in him. GM Chris Ballard believes Jones is the long-term solution, but here’s the catch: Jones might not return to form immediately, leaving the Colts in a tough spot. Should they sign him to a multi-year deal now, or wait and see? The controversy here is whether Jones is truly the franchise quarterback the Colts have been searching for since Andrew Luck’s retirement. If not, how much longer can they afford to wait?
Washington Commanders · Age 32
Jayden Daniels’ injury-plagued 2025 season highlighted just how valuable Marcus Mariota has been as a backup. Mariota kept the Commanders afloat, proving he’s more than just a stopgap. Yet, Washington has been hesitant to commit long-term, opting for consecutive one-year deals. Is this a mistake? Mariota’s performance suggests he deserves more, but the Commanders might be wary of his age and injury history. Here’s the question: Is Mariota a reliable long-term option, or should Washington look for a younger backup?
Baltimore Ravens · Age 27
The Ravens’ relationship with Tyler Huntley feels like a never-ending cycle. They let him go, he competes elsewhere, and they bring him back when Lamar Jackson gets injured. Why not just keep him in-house? Huntley has proven his value as a backup, yet the Ravens seem reluctant to commit. Is this a case of undervaluing what they have, or is there a valid reason to keep their options open? And here’s a thought: Could Huntley be more than just a backup if given the chance?
Kansas City Chiefs · Age 29
With Patrick Mahomes recovering from an ACL injury, the Chiefs need a steady hand to start the 2026 season. Gardner Minshew fits the bill perfectly. He’s a proven injury replacement, having kept the Colts in contention in 2023. But is he just a temporary solution, or could he challenge for a starting role if Mahomes’ recovery stalls? The controversy here is whether the Chiefs should invest more in their backup quarterback position, especially with Mahomes’ injury history.
Los Angeles Rams · Age 34
Matthew Stafford’s age and injury concerns make a reliable backup essential. Jimmy Garoppolo is that guy—a veteran with big-game experience. But is he the best option for the Rams moving forward? Some might argue that a younger, more mobile quarterback could better complement Stafford’s style. Is Garoppolo the safe choice, or should the Rams take a risk on someone new?
Los Angeles Chargers · Age 25
Trey Lance’s 2025 season didn’t impress many, but his preseason performance hinted at untapped potential. With Justin Herbert’s injury history, having Lance as a backup could be a game-changer. Yet, some might say Lance hasn’t proven himself worthy of a roster spot. Is he a valuable asset, or just a former high draft pick who never lived up to the hype?
Now, I want to hear from you. Which of these quarterbacks do you think should be re-signed, and which ones should their teams let walk? Are there any controversial picks here that you disagree with? Let’s debate it in the comments!
